Anne Logan / Archives / Books / Contributors / Pt. 7 / Reviews

Book Review: Black Apple by Joan Crate | I’ve Read This

ANNE LOGAN | The Black Lion Journal

by Anne Logan

In honour of the past Alberta Book Awards being given out, I wanted to highlight another wonderful book I just finished by an award-winning Alberta author Joan Crate. Black Apple follows a young Aboriginal girl named Sinopaki as she is forcefully taken from her family and brought to the residential school of St. Mark’s. Throughout her entire childhood and teens she is held there against her will until she is a young woman, firmly rooted in a religion she reluctantly practices but does not truly accept.

As I’ve said before on my blog, the difficult history of residential schools is one that I believe all Canadians should be aware of; I believe this would help eliminate the racism that the indigenous people of our country still face each and every day. However, Crate has not penned “just another residential school” story here. She writes the book from mainly two perspectives: Sinopaki’s and the head of the school, Mother Grace. Two very different characters with two very different views are expertly illustrated, giving one of the most fair accounts (that I’ve ever read) of what happened to the people caught up in this system.

Book Review: Black Apple by Joan Crate | I've Read This | BL | Black Lion Journal | Black Lion

Sinopaki is the obvious protagonist of the story and it’s her that we follow most closely. She is a rambunctious child, therefore she is beaten by the nuns (as many children were in residential schools); but she also shows great intelligence. Because of this spark, she is tutored personally by the head nun and kept from her family to continue at the school, even in the summertime when the other students are finally allowed home. Aside from being clever, she has special visions where she sees people’s spirits leave their body and can even see ghosts of people who have died in the school grounds. Many children died there each year (again, a true fact of history) so she is literally haunted by dead schoolmates regularly.

In comparison, Mother Grace is also suffering. Although she could be viewed as the villain of the story (it’s her alone that keeps Sinopaki from her family), Crate attempts to depict her in a positive light at times. Mother Grace is struggling her way through a male-dominated system that cares more about bottom lines than the children themselves. She truly believes she is helping the children by keeping them at the school, but she does regret her actions when she sees how much she has hurt Sinopaki. As I’ve read before, many clergy who participated in the residential school system did believe they were doing good, but unfortunately there were many abusers alongside them, which is why these experiences were so traumatic.

Although it’s a difficult subject matter, the story has a somewhat happy ending. I finished the book feeling positive, which is no easy feat when exploring a topic like this. And of course, I’m proud to say that Crate lives in my local digs of Calgary, which is another great reason to pick up Black Apple.

• • •

About The Author

Book Review: Black Apple by Joan Crate | I've Read This | BL | Black Lion Journal | Black Lion

Photograph (c) David Chittick

Joan Crate was born in Yellowknife, North­west Territories, and was brought up with pride in her Indigenous heritage. She taught literature and creative writing at Red Deer College, Alberta, for over 20 years. Her first book of poetry, Pale as Real Ladies: Poems for Pauline Johnson, has become a classic. Her first novel, Breathing Water, was shortlisted for the Commonwealth Book Award (Canada) and the Books in Canada First Novel Award in 1989. She is a recipient of the Bliss Carman Award for Poetry and her last book of poetry, SubUrban Legends, was awarded Book of the Year by the Writers’ Guild of Alberta. She lives with her family in Calgary.

Joan Crate | Simon and Schuster | Buy Black Apple


BL | Black Lion Journal | Black Lion | Christina Lydia
Review By Anne Logan Of I’ve Read This | The Black Lion is a humble interdisciplinary journal that values your voice. Visit the submissions page to learn more about submitting to the Journal’s sections or to The Wire’s Dream Magazine. | Copyright Policy

Header image from Amazon book page.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.